TL;DR
Get backup power and energy gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Matter Alpha’s first-month account describes replacing most of an apartment’s older Zigbee equipment with Matter devices for lighting, controls and other smart-home functions. The writer reports easier consolidation, but says Matter versions of some wall switches lack features available through their manufacturers’ own ecosystems.
Matter Alpha’s first-month report describes replacing most of the writer’s older Zigbee smart-home equipment with Matter devices in a new apartment, while finding that some Matter-connected switches did not expose features available in their manufacturers’ ecosystems. The account offers a practical snapshot of how a system built around the shared standard performed across lighting, controls and home platforms; it is one user’s experience, not a controlled test of every Matter product.
The writer began by powering on existing controllers and removing many older device entries, while keeping most network credentials unchanged. Home Assistant served as the primary controller for new Matter devices. The writer then shared devices needing direct phone control with Apple Home and used Home Assistant Link, previously called Home Assistant Cloud, to connect Google Home and Amazon Alexa.
The setup included Matter lighting and controls alongside some bridge and software options for devices that were not Matter-native. The report says the writer retired some standalone Zigbee bridges that were no longer needed and used software such as eWeLink Cube and Homey Self-Hosted Server to bring certain proprietary LAN devices into Matter. The account describes this as reducing physical clutter and simplifying maintenance; it does not quantify either effect.
Lighting came first. The writer installed about 10 Aqara EU Switch H2 and Dimmer Switch H2 units using Thread, for fans, lights and ceiling fixtures, as well as ceiling lights, pendant fixtures, bulbs and lamps from several brands. The switches’ support for neutral-free wiring helped with retrofitting existing wall boxes, according to the report. But the writer said their Matter implementation lacked decoupled relay mode and offered few dimmer configuration options, leaving the writer to consider alternatives.
Matter’s Switch Feature Trade-Offs
The report highlights a practical distinction for buyers: cross-brand connectivity does not necessarily bring feature parity. A device may join a Matter-based setup while offering fewer controls than it does through the manufacturer’s own app or protocol. For households deciding whether to replace working Zigbee equipment, that can affect day-to-day functions such as how wall switches interact with smart bulbs.
The account also shows how a multi-platform home can be organized around one controller while still sharing selected devices with Apple, Google and Amazon services. That approach may appeal to people who want to mix brands, but the report’s experience suggests that compatibility should be checked feature by feature, especially for wall controls and dimmers.
Products Worth Considering
LEVOIT Vital 100S-P Smart Air Purifier with Washable Pre-Filter
Samsung 42-Inch Class OLED S90F 4K Smart TV (2025)
Samsung 48-Inch S90H OLED 4K Smart TV (2026)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Apartment Setup Was Built
The writer says moving into a larger apartment created an opportunity to start over and reduce reliance on older protocols. The previous setup combined Zigbee switches, HomeKit fixtures and some Matter lamps. During the first month, the writer replaced nearly all older Zigbee devices with Matter products across several categories, though the supplied account focuses most closely on hubs, lighting and switches.
Matter is designed to let compatible smart-home products work across supported platforms. In this setup, Home Assistant handled initial device additions, with selected devices then exposed to other services. Some equipment still relied on bridges or software integration, so the report’s “all-Matter” description refers to the direction of the system rather than evidence that every connected device communicated natively over Matter.
“They are no better than their Zigbee counterparts over Matter right now.”
— Matter Alpha report author
Limits of One Home’s Test
The account covers one apartment and one user’s first month; it does not establish how the same products perform across other networks, controller combinations or software versions. The supplied material gives no systematic reliability measurements, failure rates or comparison against an otherwise identical Zigbee setup.
It also does not detail the later results for every device category named in its introduction, including climate, sensors and power monitoring. The report’s switch criticisms describe the writer’s experience, and the material does not clarify whether firmware updates or manufacturer-specific settings could change those limitations.
More Devices and Switch Options
The writer says the current switches are being used while they look for better neutral-free wall-control alternatives. The report does not give a date for a replacement or a planned follow-up test. Further reporting would need to establish whether software or firmware changes address the missing functions, and how the rest of the apartment’s Matter devices perform over a longer period.
For readers considering a similar setup, the report points to two practical checks before buying: confirm that a device supports the required function through the intended platform, and verify whether it needs a bridge or separate integration. The account’s next meaningful milestone is a longer-term update on switch alternatives and performance across the full system.
Key Questions
What did the Matter Alpha report cover?
It described the writer’s first month setting up a new apartment with Matter devices, focusing on controllers, lighting and wall switches. It is a personal account, not a broad product test.
Which controller did the writer use first?
The writer added new Matter devices through Home Assistant, then shared selected devices with Apple Home and used Home Assistant Link for Google Home and Amazon Alexa.
What problem did the writer report with the switches?
The writer said the Matter-connected Aqara switches lacked decoupled relay mode for smart-bulb automations and had very limited dimmer configuration options in the setup.
Did every device in the home use Matter natively?
The account describes a system moving toward Matter, but also mentions bridges and software integrations for proprietary LAN devices. It does not establish that every connected product communicated natively over Matter.
What remains to be tested?
The supplied report does not provide longer-term reliability data or detailed results for all the climate, sensor and power-monitoring devices mentioned. The writer also has not yet reported whether they replace the switches or find alternatives.
Source: matteralpha.com
